In a landmark decision, the Federal Maritime Commission (FMC) has ruled in favor of Samsung Electronics America (SEA), awarding $3.68 million in reparations from ZIM Integrated Shipping Services Ltd. The case marks a significant move by the FMC to address and curb “unreasonable practices” in container shipping, especially related to demurrage and detention charges during the pandemic-induced supply chain disruptions.

Background of the Dispute

The dispute arose from SEA’s complaint involving approximately 10,000 charges across nearly 3,000 containers. These charges were related to “store-door” shipments during the tumultuous period between May 2020 and June 2022 when COVID-19 severely impacted global logistics.

SEA accused ZIM of multiple violations under the Shipping Act, including unjust billing practices, retaliation, and lack of proper invoice documentation. Investigations revealed that delays were often outside of SEA’s control, caused mainly by port congestion or carrier-imposed cargo holds.

Key Findings and Decision

Chief Administrative Law Judge Erin M. Wirth likened the situation to “managing a group project” where delays and responsibilities were intertwined but emphasized that ZIM’s billing methods were particularly unreasonable. The FMC concluded that ZIM’s practices violated Section 41102(c) of the Shipping Act, with evidence of multiple billing errors and unjustified demurrage and detention fees.

Implications for the Shipping Industry

The ruling sends a strong message to carriers about the need for transparent billing practices, fair assessment of delays, and improved communication with consignees. It also sets a legal precedent for future disputes over demurrage and detention charges.

---

Key Data Summary

Item	Details
Ruling Authority	Federal Maritime Commission (FMC)
Awarded Amount	$3.68 million to Samsung Electronics America (SEA)
Carrier Involved	ZIM Integrated Shipping Services Ltd.
Period of Dispute	May 2020 – June 2022
Number of Containers	~3,000
Number of Disputed Charges	~10,000
Major Violations	Unjust billing, retaliation, improper invoicing, unreasonable practices
Shipping Act Section Cited	Section 41102(c)
Main Causes of Delays	Port congestion, carrier-imposed cargo holds
Judge’s Observation	Delays involved shared responsibility, but billing errors by ZIM were unjustified